By Brittany Bailey, Communications Specialist, CDIA
As privacy laws continue to evolve across the country, policymakers face an important challenge: protecting consumers’ personal information without restricting the responsible use of data that helps keep them safe. States are introducing new privacy requirements, revisiting existing laws, and expanding oversight of how businesses collect and share information. While these efforts aim to strengthen consumer protections, overlapping regulations can create confusion and unintended consequences.
These challenges were at the center of CDIA’s recent webinar, The Privacy Landscape in Motion: What’s Changing and What’s Next for 2027, featuring Tallman Johnson, CDIA’s Senior Vice President of Government Relations and Policy; Zachary Taylor, CDIA’s Senior Director of Government Relations; and Kim Phan, Partner at Troutman Pepper Locke. Their discussion reinforced the importance of privacy policies that protect personal information while preserving the responsible data use essential to fraud prevention, accurate credit reporting, and consumer financial security.
With 24 states having enacted comprehensive privacy laws and additional legislation expected in 2027, the regulatory landscape is becoming increasingly complex. At the federal level, laws such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) already establish important protections governing consumer information. However, new state requirements do not always align with these existing safeguards. Different rules for accessing, correcting, or deleting personal information can make it harder for consumers to understand their rights and for businesses to meet their obligations. As lawmakers consider additional protections, ensuring consistency between federal and state requirements will be critical to creating a privacy framework that works for everyone.
One of the greatest concerns involves privacy requirements that could unintentionally weaken fraud prevention efforts. Data plays an essential role in helping businesses verify identities, detect suspicious activity, and prevent criminals from opening fraudulent accounts. However, broad data deletion requirements that fail to distinguish between different uses of information could limit the effectiveness of these protections. During the webinar, speakers highlighted New Jersey’s data broker legislation as an example of how new requirements can create uncertainty for businesses that use information for legitimate consumer protection purposes. Giving consumers greater control over their personal information is important, but privacy protections should not come at the expense of the tools that help safeguard their identities and financial well-being.
Emerging technologies are adding another layer of complexity. Artificial intelligence is changing how businesses process information and how consumers exercise their rights, including the growing use of AI tools to submit disputes and privacy requests. While these technologies can make it easier for consumers to engage with businesses, they also create challenges in determining which laws apply and how requests should be handled. At the same time, shifting political priorities and increased state enforcement activity are expected to shape privacy policy in 2027. These developments underscore the need for clear requirements, thoughtful coordination, and compliance practices that adapt to changing technologies without compromising existing consumer protections.
As policymakers look toward 2027, the focus should be on developing privacy policies that work together rather than creating additional layers of conflicting requirements. Consumers deserve meaningful control over their personal information, clear rights, and strong protections against fraud and identity theft. Achieving these goals requires recognizing that responsible data use is part of consumer protection, not separate from it. CDIA will continue working with policymakers and industry stakeholders to support balanced privacy policies that complement existing federal laws and preserve the benefits of accurate, secure, and responsible information sharing. Ultimately, the success of privacy regulation should be measured not by the number of new restrictions enacted, but by how effectively those policies protect consumers while supporting a safe and reliable financial system.
